
Talk to most prosecutors and defense attorneys when they’re off duty — and maybe have a couple of drinks in them — and most of them will admit a simple truth: People often lie in court to try to shape the verdict; defendants often lie; accusers often lie; witnesses often lie; police often lie. The purpose of a criminal trial is to let a jury sift through all the testimony and evidence presented in court — sometime including lies and deceptions — and try to discern the essential truth at the heart of the matter: Did the defendant commit a crime beyond a reasonable doubt?
Unfortunately, due to an inexperienced District Attorney Cyrus Vance, Jr. (the son of Jimmy Carter’s Secretary of State) wanting to protect his reputation in the press, and a scandal-hungry media anxious to publicize every rumor about both former International Monetary Fund head Dominique Strauss-Kahn and the hotel maid who accused him of sexual assault, a jury may never have a chance to decide Strauss-Kahn’s guilt or innocence.
Instead, the case has already been tried twice in the scandal-mad media, using strategic leaks from the DA’s office and the police: First when DSK was initially arrested, held without bail, and found guilty by the media; second when doubts emerged about the truthfulness of his accuser in other parts of her life, the DA went to the press with the doubts in order to cover his office prior mistakes, and the media is now trying the accuser as a liar, gold-digger, and possibly even a prostitute.
If DA Vance now drops the charges, both DSK and his accuser may end up with their reputations shattered, without a jury ever getting a chance to sort through the evidence in court.
First, when DSK was initially accused, the DA and the media treated him as though he were already guilty, with the DA’s office arraigning him in view of media photographers unshaven and looking guilty, indicting him in five days to prevent him from getting bail instead of waiting longer to investigate, and telling the press that his accuser’s story was highly